Rachael Lindberg, MS, LPC
Afterglow Counseling & Coaching, PLLC
The New Year is a time of optimism and goal-setting, but resolutions quickly become a pressure-filled exercise for many. Missing a resolution, even once, can spark guilt, especially for those who struggle with perfectionism. That inner voice may whisper, “You failed,” turning what could be a learning experience into a source of shame.
But resolutions aren’t meant to be a perfect streak. They’re about growth, learning, and finding what works for you. Let’s explore how to reframe guilt and embrace imperfection with actionable strategies and examples.
1. Challenge All-or-Nothing Thinking
Perfectionism often convinces us that anything less than perfection is failure. This rigid mindset makes one missed workout or skipped task feel catastrophic, overshadowing the progress already made. Example: If you set a goal to journal every day and miss a few, pause and ask yourself, “Does missing one day erase the benefits of the other days I journaled?” Of course not. Instead of scrapping the goal altogether, treat it like a reset button and pick it back up.
Reframe the narrative: “I missed a few days, but I can start again tomorrow. Progress is still progress.”
2. Focus on Progress, Not Perfection
It’s easy to overlook small wins when perfectionism demands massive leaps. But real change happens incrementally, and celebrating those steps helps build momentum. Example: Say your resolution is to cook more meals at home, but after a long week, you order takeout twice. Instead of fixating on the takeout, focus on the two meals you did cook. Each one was a step toward your goal, and that effort matters. Try keeping a list of small wins to remind yourself that growth is cumulative, not instantaneous.
3. Revisit Your “Why”
When guilt takes over, reconnecting with your deeper motivation can shift your focus from judgment to purpose. Why did you set this resolution in the first place? Was it to feel healthier, spend more time with family, or practice self-care? Example: If your resolution is to exercise more and you’ve been skipping workouts, think about the real reason behind your goal. Is it about feeling strong, having more energy, or improving mental health? Instead of viewing missed days as failures, see them as moments to recalibrate your approach. Anchor yourself in your “why” to reignite your commitment.
4. Practice Self-Compassion
When perfectionism leads to guilt, self-compassion is your best ally. Treat yourself with the same kindness you would offer a friend who feels discouraged. Example: Imagine a friend tells you they skipped their resolution to meditate for a week. You wouldn’t say, “Well, you failed—just give up.” You’d likely reassure them that it’s okay and encourage them to try again. Offer yourself that same grace. Pause and say, “I’m human, and I’m learning. This isn’t about being perfect; it’s about trying.”
5. Reevaluate and Adjust
Resolutions aren’t set in stone. They’re meant to evolve as your needs and circumstances change. If a goal feels too rigid or unattainable, it’s okay to adjust it. Example: If you initially planned to work out six days a week but find it unsustainable, adjust your goal to three days. Shifting the goal doesn’t mean you’re giving up—it means you’re creating space for success that aligns with your reality. Reevaluating resolutions can actually make them more effective by keeping them achievable and meaningful.
Moving Forward with Grace as You Cope with Feelings of Guilt and Failure from New Year's Resolution
Resolutions aren’t about perfection—they’re about showing up for yourself in ways that feel intentional. Missing a day, a week, or even a month doesn’t diminish your efforts or your worth. It’s simply part of being human. By challenging perfectionistic thinking, celebrating progress, and practicing self-compassion, you can create a more sustainable approach to personal growth. Feelings of guilt and failure when you miss a New Year's Resolution don’t have to hold you back. Instead, let it be a gentle nudge to reconnect with your “why” and move forward with kindness and flexibility. Remember, the most important resolution isn’t about what you achieve—it’s about how you treat yourself along the way.
Interested in individual counseling, sex therapy, or relationship counseling? Submit a Contact Form to schedule a free 15-minute initial phone consultation with Rachael Lindberg, LPC!